(Click on the link below to see the list)
I will tell you!
Besides the glaring fact that Sherlock Holmes is NOT a Christmas movie….(I am open on Die Hard though)
This list from IMD is a typical list of top Christmas movies, similar to any you may find. Other similar lists including “top grossing” Christmas movies, etc..
The word “wrong” may have been a feeble attempt to stir the pot a bit….
This list is certainly “telling” just how far culture and society has indeed moved away from the true meaning of Christmas. I have watched every one of these top 25 Christmas movies, and to my recollection only 3 of them state the actual meaning of Christmas, with The Nativity depicting the historical accuracy and significance of this most beloved holiday.
Santa Clause, of course, is the main character in the vast majority of these movies, with Jesus taking a back seat (with the exception of Little Drummer Boy, A Charlie Brown Christmas and The Nativity…and hey at least that movie made it to #7)
It’s a Wonderful Life and A Christmas Carol at least get to the meaning of giving, love, faith and angels (in some regards)
In youth group this past week we discussed the question “Is Christmas still a Christian holiday”. The majority of people who celebrate do not attend any church service or mass, nor participate in Advent or read the Biblical story.
Moreover, an increasing number of non-Christian countries are beginning to celebrate Christmas including Muslim and Hindu countries. While I am in favor of that (in theory) I have been told from friends who live there that the commercial interests and American culture has infiltrated their countries, much to the display of the traditionalists. Santa, Rudolf, colorful lights, trees, presents, and well…more gift giving has won the day and America is to thank. But nowhere, literally nowhere in these cultures does the story of Jesus’ birth and theological impact of the incarnation ever make it into the celebration…thus proving (in some way) that Christmas is no longer a Christian holiday.
Perhaps this is good as the commercialism and consumerism of the holiday (as celebrated by Americans at least) has moved in stark contrast to the ideals of that first Christmas and Jesus’ message “It is better to give than to receive.”
Let me be honest for a moment.
I struggle with this because as my two boys grow up, there is a huge part of me that wants them to be just as excited with Santa, Rudolph, Frosty and opening shiny boxes on Christmas Day as I was. I do not believe this is bad.
However, it is very easy to let our attention and affection gravitate solely towards those aspects rather than the simple, humble and profound message of God becoming one of us…”Immanuel”